Friday, July 30, 2010

Can I Practice Yoga if I am a Catholic?

I stop by my old friend Joseph Fromm's blog - Good Jesuit, Bad Jesuit - from time to time to see what new nugget he has mined from the Internet. On my latest foray into the thicket, I came upon this little gem:


Father John Hardon, S.J. On the Incompatibility of Yoga and Hinduism with Catholicism

Joseph has taken this post from the website of Patrick Madrid. I have no idea who Patrick Madrid is, but he does seem to have a nice blog and I appreciate his focus on the topic of atheism and its proponents.

That Mr. Fromm finds this an important nugget is not surprising. In an exchange with Joseph several years ago, he decried my practice of Yoga. Now, citing the backing of Father Hardon - a Jesuit of my own Detroit Province - he surely sees this as a ratification of his own position concerning the incompatibility of Yoga practice with the Catholic Faith.





Father Hardon begins with a pretty circular statement: "Yoga is incompatible with Catholicism because the best known practice of Hindu spirituality is Yoga." I don't know about you, but this seems like a pretty vacuous statement: I understand the subject of the sentence but it seems that the predicate is a rehash of the subject. No new information has been added!

A little bit later in the essay, the venerable Father Hardon writes:

Indian spirituality is perhaps best known by the practice of yoga, derived from the root yuj to unite or yoke, which in context means union with the Absolute. Numerous stages are distinguished in the upward progress toward the supreme end of identification: by means of knowledge with the deity; the practice of moral virtues and observance of ethical rules; bodily postures; control of internal and external senses; concentration of memory and meditation–finally terminating in total absorption (samadhi), “when the seer stands in his own nature.”
Although the psychic element is far more important in yoga than the body, the latter is more characteristic of this method of Hindu liberation. Its purpose is to secure the best disposition of body for the purpose of meditation. The practice begins with a simple device for deep and slow breathing. 
In my bedroom, where I have my collection of Yoga DVD's (in addition to the Insanity workout), I have three crucifixes hanging on the walls. I hung these on the wall in such a way that, regardless of the pose I'm holding, I'm facing one of them. When I am holding poses for one to three minutes, I find that my mind relaxes and I'm able to contemplate the cross and the person upon it. My stress-relieving exercises becomes, each day, a time of profound meditation on the cross. When my body aches or my muscles burn, I breath more deeply and unite my physical discomfort with the cross: the health of my body and the health of my spirit are ineluctably intertwined.




Let me say two things about why I think that Yoga is an excellent physical practice that, done well, is profoundly helpful for an authentic Catholic/Christian spirituality.

  • Recall the dictum of Saint Thomas Aquinas: Anima mea non est ego (my soul is not me). We are embodied subjects! The Christian life is not about saving the souls bereft of the body - we do profess the resurrection of the body, after all - and our future lives in the eternal city of God will be fully embodied. The practice of Yoga helps to integrate the mind and body and brings about a heightened level of focus and awareness. After even the most tumultuous day, I find that thirty minutes of Yoga practice restores balance to my life, eases tension, and enables me to enter into prayer fully and openly.                                                                                                                  
I mention this because, very often, people interpret Christianity in a quasi-gnostic manner where we think that all that matters is the soul and that the body is irrelevant. Plato might have agreed with this, as well as the Cathars, but an orthodox Catholic cannot. Do recall that the first confession of faith comes from Saint Thomas who cries out, "My Lord and my God" only after he touches the wounds of the Risen Christ. 
  • Drawing from my own Ignatian tradition, I might recall that Ignatius dedicates Annotations [73-90] to talk about the role of the body in our prayer. Ignatius was profoundly sensitive to our embodied natures and offers sage counsel in regard to the role of the body in prayer. 
These are two simple points, to be sure, but I think they're valid and important to make.
Let me conclude by noting that I am not advocating that a Catholic subscribe to the panentheistic worldview decried by Father Hardon. I think it is entirely possible - and I use myself as an example - that one can engage in the physical practice of Yoga as a form of exercise without having to subscribe to any of its spiritual tenets. If you go to Target, you can purchase Rodney Yee's DVD's and you'll find not a single mention of Hindu spirituality: what you get is a really good workout, not a form of proselytizing.

I do, however, think that any type of physical activity has tremendous spiritual benefits and that, of the ones I've engaged in, Yoga does incline me more toward prayerful meditation than, say, football. Perhaps here my Jesuitical nature, born of the Spiritual Exercises, blossoms. Ignatius, in the First Principle and Foundation [23] uses the Latin phrase Tantum Quantum ("to the extent"). "To the extent" that Yoga helps a person to enter more deeply into the mystery of the Christian faith, I think it is wholly appropriate for Yoga to be practiced. If it leads person away from the cross, cripples the ability to pray, effaces the radical transcendence of God, or negates the dogmatically held beliefs of the Church, then it should be avoided.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Did you see the post where Joseph quotes John Hardon as saying he would never recommend someone join the Jesuits...and then Joseph CUTS OUT Hardon's suggestion that young men join...THE LEGIONARIES???

I love it.

Ryan Duns, SJ said...

He is selective, that's for sure.

Anonymous said...

I have been reading all I can find on Yoga and its compatibility with Catholicism. Your comments were interesting...I specifically Googled "Jesuits and Yoga" because I consider Ignatius to be my inspiration! I am still a bit confused though. I was listening to a talk show this morning and the host (a show on EWTN) really made Yoga seem evil and that one doing it is opening oneself to darkness. It kind of freaked me out. I teach in a Catholic school (religion) and I don't want to be a bad influence. I guess I need to pray and "discern" the desirability of my continuing yoga.

Anonymous said...

Apparently there's a recent post here (http://goodjesuitbadjesuit.blogspot.com/2010/08/jesuit-looks-at-problems-with-yoga.html) which links to Fr. Mitch Pacwa, S.J., a pretty well-regarded Jesuit himself, talking about the spiritual dangers of Yoga (episode 3). John Hardon, Mitch Pacwa, all these discerning Jesuits, maybe it's worth further consideration before accepting yoga as something 'harmless', especially when it concerns our spiritual state.

Ryan Duns, SJ said...

Father Pacwa is, in his assessment, simply wrong about the intentions behind Yoga. I have never been encouraged to "be like a tree" when I hold a tree pose; rather, I try to relax my muscles and try to maintain balance.

Father Pacwa is, as one person commented, setting up a straw man. The fact that SOME strands of Yoga may encourage this -- those DVDs put out by Gaiam do not -- does not mean that ALL forms of yoga are seducing practitioners into pantheism.

If you don't like Yoga, don't do it. For my money, I find it extraordinarily helpful in leading me into prayer while still getting some physical exercise. If you don't like it, it's your preference, but unless you can do more than footnote two Jesuits whom you regard as having particular authority, I advise you to continue your investigation, think for yourself, and come back with a better reason.

Craig said...

Could much the same be said of Tai Chi? By that I mean, it is a good moving meditation asa a prep for prayer?

blonde yogini said...

Hi There, I am a former theology teacher at a Jesuit high school in SF and I practice yoga regularly. It edifies my faith greatly and brings me closer to God, no doubt. The skepticism and ignorance in the Catholic church about yoga bothers me supremely! In my blog, I sometimes write about how the two work together in my life. Check it out if you would like. Thank you for posting this!

Anonymous said...

For some catholics everything seems harmful. In poland, where I live, priests preaching that practically EVERYTHING is bad for you, and you should kneel down and pray 24/7. Meditation - satan, yoga - satan, computer games - guess what... for fundies even positive thinking and internet are satanic :) Not to mention aikido, taekwondo...

I watch it from my buddhist perspective, and can't stop wondering where is the line when people will snap, say "father, you are mental!" and just leave him with his assumptions alone.

Anonymous said...

I was a victim of a DUI 9 years ago. I've been in and out of physical therapy over the years. I just recently took up yoga, and the first thing I noticed is how similar the two are. Yoga is much cheaper than physical therapy, and I'm hoping it will help me.

My instructor does practice Hindu, and every time he says "Spirit" I think Jesus.